As we all know, there are two cases coming before the Supreme Court (Sebelius v. Hobby Lobby Stores and Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp v. Sebelius) that argue the novel (if not insane) concept that corporations/businesses have religious liberties. Both Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Wood ground their arguments in the 1993 Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) that the contraception mandate in the Affordable Care Act (ACA aka Obamacare) places a non-acceptable burden on the religious liberties of these two corporations.
A coalition of organizations* were paying attention though and have filed an amicus brief asking the Court to rule whether or not the RFRA is even constitutional. In my view, this is a very welcome game changer. Let us hope the Supreme Court takes the brief seriously and considers the constitutionality of the RFRA.
I want to thank Lyle Denniston over at the SCOTUSBlog for writing up an easy to read article regarding this amicus brief.
*The coalition that filed the amicus brief is made up of the following organizations:
1. Freedom From Religion Foundation
2. BishopAccountability.org
3. Children's Healthcare Is A Legal Duty, Inc (CHILD, Inc)
4. Child Protection Project
5. Foundation To Abolish Child Sex Abuse
6. Survivors For Justice
7. Survivors Network Of Those Abused By Priests
Showing posts with label SCOTUSblog. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SCOTUSblog. Show all posts
Tuesday, January 28, 2014
Thursday, May 30, 2013
Let The Frivolous Lawsuits Fly
It didn't take long. It was only a little over a month ago when it was disclosed the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) did their job by giving extra scrutiny to groups applying for tax exempt status as 501(c)(4) organizations. And now, conservative "tea party" and "patriot" groups have, as Lyle Denniston over at SCOTUSBlog states, filed suit against the IRS for violating their rights due to this extra scrutiny.
Let's be clear, in order to be tax exempt as a 501(c)(4), you are to engage exclusively as a "social welfare" organization. By law, you are not allowed to be involved in politics, period. Let's also be clear, even though these conservative groups received extra scrutiny, not one of them was denied tax exempt status. Not one. Some did withdraw their applications, but not one was denied.
One would think, by watching and reading the "mainstream media" (MSM), that the IRS only gave extra scrutiny to conservative groups and only groups with "tea party" or "patriot" in their name. You would be sadly mistaken. According to the IRS Inspector General, over 300 organizations were given extra scrutiny. Of those 300, less than 100 of them were conservative groups. Plus, of those 300 groups, only one was denied tax exempt status under 501(c)(4) and it was a liberal organization.
So even though these conservative organizations were clearly political organizations, they knowingly conspired to break tax law and be subsidized by the American tax payer. To add insult to injury, they now file law suits against the IRS for giving them extra scrutiny. To be fair, none of them should have been given tax exempt status and the real scandal is that clearly political organizations are regularly given tax exempt status.
In my view, the federal judges hearing these cases should throw them out as being frivolous, as the "offended" parties clearly broke the law. Short of dismissal, these judges should rule that the law clearly states that to receive tax exempt status and the IRS has for years "misinterpreted" the statute and that these groups lose their tax exempt status.
Sadly, I don't think either will happen.
Let's be clear, in order to be tax exempt as a 501(c)(4), you are to engage exclusively as a "social welfare" organization. By law, you are not allowed to be involved in politics, period. Let's also be clear, even though these conservative groups received extra scrutiny, not one of them was denied tax exempt status. Not one. Some did withdraw their applications, but not one was denied.
One would think, by watching and reading the "mainstream media" (MSM), that the IRS only gave extra scrutiny to conservative groups and only groups with "tea party" or "patriot" in their name. You would be sadly mistaken. According to the IRS Inspector General, over 300 organizations were given extra scrutiny. Of those 300, less than 100 of them were conservative groups. Plus, of those 300 groups, only one was denied tax exempt status under 501(c)(4) and it was a liberal organization.
So even though these conservative organizations were clearly political organizations, they knowingly conspired to break tax law and be subsidized by the American tax payer. To add insult to injury, they now file law suits against the IRS for giving them extra scrutiny. To be fair, none of them should have been given tax exempt status and the real scandal is that clearly political organizations are regularly given tax exempt status.
In my view, the federal judges hearing these cases should throw them out as being frivolous, as the "offended" parties clearly broke the law. Short of dismissal, these judges should rule that the law clearly states that to receive tax exempt status and the IRS has for years "misinterpreted" the statute and that these groups lose their tax exempt status.
Sadly, I don't think either will happen.
Tuesday, March 26, 2013
California's Prop 8 at The Supreme Court - Updated - 2nd Update 2:49 pm
As I write this, the United States Supreme Courts is about to begin oral arguments in Hollingsworth v. Perry, better known as the California Prop 8 case. It is a scary proposition to have this particular Court with its conservative majority that seems hellbent on reversing the progress of civil rights in the past century to hear this case. No matter how oral arguments go today (an audio recording will be available later today), we probably won't know until June what the outcome will be when the decision is handed down.
Of course, we will all be trying to read the tea leaves of what is said in oral argument by the Justices via their questions (almost statements). And of course, all eyes and ears will be on Justice Kennedy, the author of Lawrence v. Texas as he is expected to be the swing vote. Will the Court follow in the steps of Loving v. Virginia by reaffirming the fundamental right of marriage and thus striking down gay marriage bans across the nation? Or will the Court deal a staggering blow to the marriage equality movement by declaring that Proposition 8 is constitutional and there isn't a fundamental right for same sex couples to get married?
Or will the Court punt? In my honest opinion, I think they will punt (especially if Chief Justice Roberts is the author) and they will do so in one of three ways:
A hat tip to SCOTUSblog for their incredible coverage of the marriage equality cases and also a hats off to Chris Hays who, in his final show as the host of MSNBC's UP, had a full hour discussion on the marriage equality cases before the Court featuring Dan Savage. I am including those videos below.
*UPDATE* Tom Goldstein, over at SCOTUSblog, doesn't have a lot of good things to say about oral arguments today. Kind of scary.
*2ND UPDATE* The audio recording of today's arguments have been released and I am including them here.
Of course, we will all be trying to read the tea leaves of what is said in oral argument by the Justices via their questions (almost statements). And of course, all eyes and ears will be on Justice Kennedy, the author of Lawrence v. Texas as he is expected to be the swing vote. Will the Court follow in the steps of Loving v. Virginia by reaffirming the fundamental right of marriage and thus striking down gay marriage bans across the nation? Or will the Court deal a staggering blow to the marriage equality movement by declaring that Proposition 8 is constitutional and there isn't a fundamental right for same sex couples to get married?
Or will the Court punt? In my honest opinion, I think they will punt (especially if Chief Justice Roberts is the author) and they will do so in one of three ways:
- They could declare that the Plaintiffs (the proponents of Proposition 8) do not have standing which would mean that the Ninth Circuit Courts narrow decision striking down Proposition 8 relying on Romer v. Evans.
- They could be California specific and ruling that Proposition 8 is unconstitutional based on Romer v. Evans while holding that the proponents of Proposition 8 do have standing.
- They could find that domestic partnerships (of which California has such a law) violates the 14th Amendment and thus those 9 states with domestic partnerships for same sex must allow for same sex marriage.
A hat tip to SCOTUSblog for their incredible coverage of the marriage equality cases and also a hats off to Chris Hays who, in his final show as the host of MSNBC's UP, had a full hour discussion on the marriage equality cases before the Court featuring Dan Savage. I am including those videos below.
*UPDATE* Tom Goldstein, over at SCOTUSblog, doesn't have a lot of good things to say about oral arguments today. Kind of scary.
*2ND UPDATE* The audio recording of today's arguments have been released and I am including them here.
Monday, August 29, 2011
Marriage Equality Symposium
My friends over at SCOTUSblog have been having an interesting online debate regarding same-sex marriage for the past couple of weeks. I recommend that everyone takes a bit of time and takes a look at what the various participants have been saying.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)